The 10 best settings ever, period, of all time (and I’m an expert)

Now is probably when I should back up this whole “expert” title I’ve just unceremoniously given myself.

For one thing, I consider myself an expert on everything. It’s called self obsession respect. TRY IT OUT SOMETIME.

But more significantly: I just really, really, really, reallyreallyreally super actually LOVE  a good setting.

I spew a lot of the same introspection-produced uninteresting factoids I’ve decided upon dramatically on this blog. And a lot of them have to do with the same thing: I JUST LOVE A GOOD SETTING.

This is why I say well-done magical realism is my fave genre (because what could be a better setting), and that the first Harry Potter book is one of the best, and that books don’t have to be nonstop action-packed for me to enjoy them.

It’s all because it’s all about the setting, baby!!!

I have a shelf on Goodreads (creatively, coolly, hip-young-teen-ly entitled “that setting tho”) with 35 great settings on it. (Well, 35 books. A bunch of them are from the same series. Serieses. Serieseseseseses. Whatever.)

Let’s narrow them down and rank those bad boys.

holy shit I was just casually opening books in tabs to start the narrowing-down process and I coincidentally had exactly ten. I AM MAGIC.


The two versions of Union

The Love That Split the World, Emily Henry



If this weren’t enough to get you to pick up this book, then, like. There’s also the fact that the setting is totally rad. It’s two versions of the same town (like in two dimensions – I don’t want to spoil it because you’ll get the answers IF YOU READ IT, YOU LAZY BUFFOON). It’s cool.

Don’t listen to the Goodreads average. Listen to me only exclusively always, okay? Or at least this time.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.47.28 PM


Five Fingers, Michigan

A Million Junes, Emily Henry

Surprise, surprise.

It’s almost like I’m obsessed with Emily Henry or something.

A Million Junes is more magical realism + lovely writing + Emily Henry’s amazing characters but also an even better setting???? A magicky Michigan following two feuding families???? What more could you ask for.

Maybe you could ask for more but that would only be if you haven’t read this book yet, and if you haven’t read this book yet you either a) just discovered this blog through one of my primitive marketing tactics, including but not limited to writing my blog name on a piece of paper, putting it into a bottle, and throwing it in the sea; using a ham radio and morse code to spread my Instagram @; and sending telegrams that function doubly as World War I death notices and attention-granters to my Goodreads account, or b) do not care about my opinion at all.

Either way, not reading this book is a Mistake.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.46.57 PM


Cabeswater, etc.

The Raven Cycle, Maggie Stiefvater

Review of The Raven Boys / Review of The Dream Thieves / Review of Blue Lily, Lily Blue

This is a great series. But.

If I’m being totally honest. It’s not a great series solely on the merit of its setting. Or even mostly on that. Mostly it is a great series because a certain character named Gansey lives in it. (Insert swooning sigh here, or whatever.) But the cool setting doesn’t exactly hurt.

I don’t remember where this book takes place, but I think it’s a Southern-ish state. North Carolina. West Virginia. Oh sh*t it’s totally West Virginia! Nailed it.

This is the third setting in this list and also the third magical realism one, because magical realism is the best. In this case…it’s hard to put the setting into words. And I hate doing things that are hard so I’m not going to do it. Just read it and find out for yourself. Bye!!!

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.46.38 PM


Ready Player One, Ernest Cline


And I, honestly, am full-on loving it. Also this shouldn’t be a surprise because I am, as previously mentioned upwards of one THOUSAND times, am completely setting-fixated.


The OASIS is a virtual reality world filled with puzzles, codes, and the ultimate scavenger hunt for easter eggs with a prize of some ridiculous amount of money I can’t remember. I feel like it’s, like, $11 billion. But also it might be more than that.

In other words, it’s Warcross if Warcross wasn’t boring or done. If Warcross had a compelling plot and fun characters with a brain cell to split between them and wasn’t just copying pre-existing plot-lines. That’s what we’re working with.

Fun, right?! Right.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.46.06 PM


The Wizarding World

Harry Potter, JK Rowling

Review of Book 1 / Book 2 / Book 3 / Book 4 / Book 5 / Book 6 / Book 7

I am the coolest person alive.

If I somehow hadn’t already received the formal world’s-coolest-person crown, I am about to.

Because, yes, you read that heading correctly. The Wizarding World is clocking in at a mere #6 on this countdown.



But the Wizarding World is cool.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.45.47 PM


The Lands Beyond

The Phantom Tollbooth, Norton Juster


Is there anything better in this whole world than a book that starts with a map??? Especially when the world is actually interesting. Maps are almost always pretty, but sometimes there are ones like this one that are also COOL.

The Phantom Tollbooth is one of the best children’s books EVER, and if you haven’t read it then it is one of the biggest “duh” statements of my entire human life to say YOU COMPLETELY SHOULD.

A little boy named Milo who is totally bored with the world (#same) gets a mysterious tollbooth one day after school, and when he drives his toy car through it, he ends up in a land of so many puns you could just die.

It’s amazing.

Look at that MAAAAAAAP.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.45.26 PM


The Schools for Good and Evil

The School for Good and Evil, Soman Chainani

I like fairytales. I like princesses. I like villains even more.

A couple crazy well-described schools where all of these groups coexist and also it’s (kind of, maybe, controversially) middle grade adventure, a GENRE WHICH I LOVE…

I’m a happy camper.

Kind of.

If you close one eye and ignore the plot holes and the drama and the traces of girl hate and the sexualization of twelve-year-old characters and the ridiculous degree to which the romantic subplot(s) strains against the definition of the term subplot.

But still. That setting!

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.44.16 PM


The Unbearable Universe

A Series of Unfortunate Events, Lemony Snicket

Review of Book 1 / Book 2 / Book 3 / Book 4 / TV adaptation / Others will be up as reread

It pains me to even dare put this so low as #3.

This is an AMAZING setting. The setting to end all semi-realistic settings, all creepy settings, all children’s-book settings. The setting is so unbelievably complex you will die. Actually. It’s a guarantee, I think.


This is a setting developed over one thirteen-book series, three to six spin offs, plus another four-book series, and another spin-off to that series. There are secret agents and easter eggs and allusions and motifs. The voice is creepy and meta and dark.


So here. Just look at another beautiful map.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.43.52 PM


Le Cirque des Rêves

The Night Circus, Erin Morgenstern

This was one of my favorite books for two years. Then I reread it and was delivered the crushing realization that it is Bad.

The setting, however, is not bad. The setting, in fact, is REALLY F*CKING GOOD.

I love circuses, for some reason? I love circuses, I love snacks, I love beautiful and visceral descriptions, I love magic, I love stunts, I love creativity, I love nighttime, I love black, I love white.

So this was kind of made for me. If you can ignore the instalove and terrible characters and lack of plot and comma splices. Which you should, if at all possible.

Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 8.43.12 PM


Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll

Not a single person in the world could possibly be surprised by this answer.

Not even if you’re a casual follower. Not even if you just found this blog through another one of my accounts. NOT EVEN IF you actually discovered this blog by opening up a bottle you found washed up on the shore and seeing “” written on the ancient-looking piece of paper within.

(You rub the paper with a damp teabag and burn the edges. That’s how I got it to be ancient-looking.)

Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland is not only the book I talk about the most annoyingly often (quite a feat, since I only ever talk about 10 books and they’re coincidentally all on this list), but it has one of the greatest settings of all time. And my favorite one ever. Every time I reread it I feel just as curious and fascinated and surprised and pleased as if I’m picking it up for the first time.

How gag-worthily cheesy is that?!

Screen Shot 2018-01-04 at 11.25.22 AM

Have you read any of these books? Do you agree or disagree with my list?

What are some of your favorite settings?

53 thoughts on “The 10 best settings ever, period, of all time (and I’m an expert)

  1. ZoeHaslie says:

    Great post! I loved Harry Potter and Alice in Wonderland, although I would lose my mind if I ended up in Wonderland!

    I think I would add Neverland since I looooove Peter Pan and pirates and the setting is just beautiful! ♥ Thanks for sharing this ^^

    Liked by 3 people

      • Qwertyuiop says:

        I don’t think you’ve read it (you should–and it’s middle grade, and I know how much you love that!), but definitely Nevermoor, specifically Hotel Deucalion. It’s a magic hotel (the latter) within a magic city (the former) with an elite society and epic magic powers and a giant talking cat! (If you don’t immediately add it to your TBR after hearing that, I will be extremely horrified and shocked.


  2. malanielovesfiction says:

    this post is magical because I just started taking setting seriously a few months ago. usually i just pay attention to the characters and I hardly appreciate where they’re at, but i’m on harry potter book 3, and mortal instruments book 2, and the settings are literal characters by themselves <3* intense emotional response*

    Liked by 2 people

    • emmareadstoomuch says:

      ahh that’s so true about the HP setting being like a character!!! tbh i DNFed the mortal instruments series after the 3rd book but the world in that one is très impressive too?? gah i love a good setting man

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Elizabeth says:

    The Wizarding World is so epic, I want to go to Hogwarts RIGHT NOW!
    Wonderland actually terrifies me. I think I’d be too confused to really enjoy it.
    I really, really think Narnia would be a fantastic place to visit. Because, Aslan!

    Liked by 2 people

    • emmareadstoomuch says:

      narnia is such a good one!!!! lol true wonderland would boggle the mind but hopefully exciting-ly and not scary-ly

      also yes i would not mind a quick trip to hogwarts atm


  4. Arachnid Weaver says:

    I did like the setting of the school for good and evil. I didn’t like the book, though. I imagined them closer to sixteen or seventeen. There’s no way they’re twelve. No twelve-year-old acts like that.
    My favorite setting is the Grishaverse from Six of Crows or New Occident from The Glass Sentence.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Satou Johns says:

    Self respect!!! You go girl!! I usually don’t pay that much attention to the setting… Hmm well I mean I do (not for all the books) but I sometimes do… I think I focus more on characters hmmm and personalities. Haha
    For WWII novels, I do pay a lot of attention to the setting hmmm (I even look up usually the places in the map an all xD)

    Liked by 1 person

  6. hannah says:

    i adore alice in wonderland!! (probably not as much as you though HAHA xD) but tbh if i ever found myself down there i would never make it back out.

    and YES a series of unfortunate events was THE BEST. it was so dark and morbid and depressing AND I LOVED IT.

    Liked by 1 person

    • emmareadstoomuch says:

      okay this is the most thrilling moment of my life???? you love both alice and ASoUE????? i am thrilled

      honestly just drop me right in wonderland or even in ASoUE and i’ll make a happy life for myself right there thx


  7. JanilleNG says:

    Okay, so now I definitely need to read some Emily Henry books because they sound right up my alley!

    As always, awesome review…your voice just comes through so well..and you’re hilarious! (Should I be complimenting you…I feel like that might just make the “self-obsession” worse…oh well! hahaha) 🙂 🙂 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • emmareadstoomuch says:

      YES EMILY HENRY she is so underrated and soooo good. (read A Million Junes first b/c The Love That Split the World is more polarizing!!)

      thank you!!! you are fueling my self obsession but i am actually a huge fan of that (but no seriously thank you so much <3)

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Norrie says:

    Ready Player One is seriously awesome! It made me so nostalgic that i actually went back to my video games after not playing for like 1.5 years… 😀 I had a good 6 months run afterwards. Can’t wait to see the movie. Although i have a feeling i will hate it, like i do most movies that are based on my fav books.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Haadiya @ The Starlit Reader says:

    its been a long and hard road *wipes tear* and ive finally found someone who feels the same way about warcross as i do
    also i love this post so much??? and please tell me they arent 12, my life has been a lie

    Liked by 1 person

    • emmareadstoomuch says:

      THEY’RE 12 CAN YOU BELIEVE IT ISN’T THAT GROSS?? i will spend my whole life attempting to forget that fact

      oh thank god a fellow warcross truther. thanks!!!!!

      Liked by 1 person

      • Haadiya @ The Starlit Reader says:

        I think my mind tried its best to suppress that horrible fact while I was reading a school for good and evil that I eventually forgot it for real
        The delusion was good while it lasted

        Liked by 1 person

plz give me attention

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s